Plea Agreements in Fresno? Avoid the Pitfalls.

The majority of criminal cases are resolved through plea agreements in Fresno. Plea negotiations are a "routine" method for disposing of cases, especially in the criminal justice system.  It is estimate that 90 to 95 percent cases in federal and state courts are resolved through plea bargaining.

Because plea bargaining is a common practice in all criminal courts, it is important to understand the entire process.  The United States implemented plea-bargaining primarily as a time saving device for disposing of criminal cases in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. By the 1920s, plea-bargaining evolved into an accepted practice we know today.

What is Plea-Bargaining?

There is not a standard definition for plea-bargaining, but generally, plea bargaining is any negotiations between a defendant, either with or without assistance of counsel, and the prosecuting attorney, whereby a criminal charge or potential criminal charge is resolved in some fashion other than by a trial on the merits.  In plea bargaining, both parties promise to do something or to refrain from doing something with respect to the matter.

Plea-bargaining results when a criminal defendant negotiates with the prosecutor to reduce charges or sentences. In exchange for a guilty plea, the prosecutor has many options. The prosecutor may reduce the original charges to less serious charges; drop collateral charges; assure the defendant a lenient sentence, recommend a sentencing or remain silent at sentencing. For example, a driver accused of driving while intoxicated (DUI) may negotiate a deal to plead guilty to reckless driving while consuming alcohol, a less serious offense that carries a more lenient sentence.

Why Do We Have Plea Negotiations?

The reasoning for plea negotiations is to save time and expense, resolve cases are more quickly, and avoid uncertainty at trial.  Defendants’ risk of harsher punishment at trial is the predominant concern, along with a promises of immediate release from custody, shorter sentences, or reduction in charges, especially when a felony is reduced to a misdemeanor.

The likelihood of plea bargaining increases when certain factors exist.  A defendant will be more inclined to enter a plea when the crime is serious, when the defendant has a prior criminal record, the evidence against the defendant is strong, the detention of the individual; and, the use of a public defender versus a private attorney.

There are many proponents to plea bargaining, but it also leads to major criticism.  In a previously article I wrote fifteen years ago, the same criticisms exists today:

First, there is not a balancing of bargaining power. Prosecutors have considerably more power in the bargaining process than the defendant. This unfair bargaining power permits prosecutors to intrude on judicial functions. With successful negotiations, the criminal justice system allows prosecutors to predetermine the sentence a particular defendant receives.

Second, plea negotiations allow practitioners to rapidly finish cases without taking into account the defendant's best interest. These bargaining practices become a daily habit for a large percentage of prosecutors and defense attorneys. The ease of pleading defendants enables practitioners to utilize the negotiation process as an initial mechanism, instead of a viable option.

The last major criticism of plea-bargaining is the general notion of how it enables offenders to receive lighter punishments in exchange for guilty pleas. The public, the primary advocate opposing negotiation agreements, complains that criminal defendants "get away" with their criminal behavior. Defendants are only receiving inconsequential sentences compared to the sentence they would normally receive without plea-bargaining. Critics believe these criminal defendants do not receive their just punishment for the crimes they commit. The legislature, responding to this attack by the public, continues to make attempts at curbing the use of plea-bargaining." For example, in 1982, the California voters approved Proposition 8, also known as the "Victims Bill of Rights," yet plea-bargaining continues to thrive.

Should We Give Up Plea Bargaining?

Plea bargaining is an inherent part of the court system and banning the use of plea bargaining is unrealistic. A more realistic solution is to allow judges and defense attorneys to have a greater role to level the balance of power the prosecutor has in plea agreements.  In some counties, judges refuse to be a part of plea negotiations, which hinder the entire courts.  Defendants are forced to wait trial longer and are denied their due process rights.

When a judge becomes a part of the plea bargaining process, defendants can expect an overall benefit because it evens the playing field. Judges that mediate the negotiations between the parties are able to hear the issues and problems with the case in order to give guidance to achieve a just result.  The court may point out the weaknesses of each party’s cases, may make recommendations to the parties as to the case, along with the possible sentencing the defendant may face by going to trial.

What if the DA Refuses to Deal?

Even if the district attorney refuses to plea bargain, the defendant may attempt to obtain an indicated from the court.  Judges may not reduce charges on its own motion, but a judge may reduce a sentence in many cases, as long as the court follows the sentencing guidelines. When that occurs, defendants plead to the charges and the judge will give the sentence originally indicated.

How Do I Know If I Should Plea-Bargain?

The best way to decide if plea bargaining is right for you is to discuss your case with your lawyer. If you were recently arrested, contact an experienced criminal defense lawyer that understands to court and plea bargaining before your decide if it is the correct decision for your case. It is important that you do not enter any plea until you have reviewed the evidence against you and there is sufficient evidence against you. If you have any questions about your case, call us today to discuss your case.

Posted on
May 25, 2016
in
Fresno Criminal Law Posts
category
plea bargain, plea negotiations, plea agreements, criminal law, criminal lawyer pleas, guilty pleas, criminal charges

17 Best Tips To Find the Best Criminal or Drunk Driving Lawyer in Fresno

Facing criminal or drunk driving charges in Fresno is serious. Find the right criminal and DUI lawyer in Fresno.
Criminal
Tina Barberi, DUI and criminal lawyer in Fresno will fight to win your criminal and DUI case.
Tina M. Barberi
March 1, 2019
When you are facing criminal or drunk driving charges in Fresno, find out why you need a lawyer and what to look for when hiring legal counsel. Here are 17 tips that can help you find the best lawyer for you and your criminal case.

Bailing out of the Fresno County Jail

A Fresno lawyer is able to help you understand the bailing out process in Fresno and get a bail bonds company of you.
Criminal
Tina Barberi, DUI and criminal lawyer in Fresno will fight to win your criminal and DUI case.
Tina M. Barberi
April 2, 2015
What is bail and why do I need it? Learn the ins and outs of bail and how to stay out of jail in Fresno. When facing criminal charges, it is important to know what your rights are concerning bail and whether you should use it.

California AB 1950 and Reduction in the Length of Probation in Fresno

CA AB 1950 reduce probation with dui and criminal defense lawyer in Fresno
Criminal
Tina Barberi, DUI and criminal lawyer in Fresno will fight to win your criminal and DUI case.
Tina M. Barberi
December 22, 2020
On January 1, 2021, California's new law, AB 1950, will reduce the length of probation for most criminal charges. Now, many people convicted of a felony or a misdemeanor will receive a shorter probation sentence.

Fresno County Tough on Petty Theft Charges

Petty theft and shoplifting in Fresno will be prosecuted without having the proper criminal lawyer that understands theft charges.
Criminal
Tina Barberi, DUI and criminal lawyer in Fresno will fight to win your criminal and DUI case.
Tina M. Barberi
April 16, 2015
Have you been arrested or accused of petty theft? If so, you need to read the steps you need to take to keep from getting a petty theft conviction in Fresno County. This blog will explain the charge and how you can fight it.

Saving Lives: Protecting Patients with Marijuana

Drug and marijuana cases can be fought when you have the right criminal law attorney in Fresno. Free consult to discuss your case.
Criminal
Criminal, Traffic and DUI defense Fresno, CA
Law Offices
October 6, 2015
Questions on medical marijuana in the state of California? See what the problems with production and transportation of medical marijuana in the state and see what you can do to protect yourself as a user and patient.

Don't Press Your Luck This Saint Patrick's Day!

Drunk driving on March 17 is dangerous and you will likely be arrested if you are pulled over by Fresno police officers.
DUI
Criminal, Traffic and DUI defense Fresno, CA
Law Offices
March 16, 2015
Have some green beer and relax this Saint Patrick's Day. There is no need to drive this year. Check out this new app that will keep you save as well as out of jail. With this app, you can count your lucky stars by not driving.

Who Let the Dogs Out? National Dog Day!

Dogs are the best, especially on National Dog Day, even when I am reading the law books at Tina Barberi's law firm
Our Firm
Criminal, Traffic and DUI defense Fresno, CA
Law Offices
August 26, 2015
Hooray, today is National Dog Day! We love our four-legged friends and want to show our special thanks for the love they always give us. Meet our best friends and then tell your special pooch how much they mean to you as well.

4th of July – Don’t Go Out With A BANG!

Drinking and fireworks do not go together when you drive. A Fresno DUI lawyer with a great record for success can help you.
Our Firm
Criminal, Traffic and DUI defense Fresno, CA
Law Offices
July 2, 2015
Do not let the firecrackers blow up in your face by drinking and driving on the 4th of July. Police are out to arrest drunk drivers so check out our tips to have a safe and sane holiday this year in order to stay out of jail.

Caution: Don't Even Think About Driving with Alcohol!

Fresno defense attorneys that fight DUI cases understand the laws for DUI probation cases, including alcohol levels.
Traffic
Tina Barberi, DUI and criminal lawyer in Fresno will fight to win your criminal and DUI case.
Tina M. Barberi
May 18, 2015
If you have received a conviction for a DUI, it is important to not take it lightly. See tips and tricks for being on DUI probation in order to stay out of court and jail. You may be surprised how easy it is to violate probation.

DUIs and DMV Help: Save My Driver's License!

DMV hearings are complicated and without an attorney, you can lose your license for a long time. Call an experienced DUI lawyer today.
Traffic
Tina Barberi, DUI and criminal lawyer in Fresno will fight to win your criminal and DUI case.
Tina M. Barberi
September 16, 2015
Have you been arrested for a DUI lately? If so, read this important information regarding DMV hearings and how they are separate from your criminal court matter. Contacting DMV to request a DMV hearing can help you - see how.

Spring Clean Your Criminal Record Now!

A criminal record does not go away without work. We will make sure you qualify for 1203.4 relief before you hire us.
Criminal
Tina Barberi, DUI and criminal lawyer in Fresno will fight to win your criminal and DUI case.
Tina M. Barberi
March 30, 2015
If you are looking to cleaning your record, this is the perfect time to start. Your criminal record will stay on your record until you do something about it. Find out how easy it can be to clear your record with an experienced lawyer.

Any rights in our car? US Supreme Court Says No!

Traffic lawyer in Fresno will defend unconstitutional searches and seizures by police in California. Make sure to hire an attorney.
Traffic
Tina Barberi, DUI and criminal lawyer in Fresno will fight to win your criminal and DUI case.
Tina M. Barberi
April 20, 2015
Are you safe from police intrusion? Find out what the Supreme Court said about officers and their mistakes. If the officer can be wrong about the law, then why can't we? See how you can protect yourself when driving in Fresno.

You Might Also Like