Cellphone Location Data and Privacy in Fresno

Recently the U.S. Supreme Court had the opportunity to decide on whether police need to obtain a search warrant to examine cellphone location information held by wireless carriers.  However, the court declined to answer the question, rising the concern of how well wireless carriers protect privacy.

Why wasn’t a search warrant needed?

The United States had obtained a court order asking the wireless carrier to disclose location data from a suspect’s cellphone, without first obtaining a warrant.   They relied on a provision of the 1987 Federal Stored Communications Act, stating probable cause is not needed to obtain customer records.

In addition, the court recognized in Smith v. Maryland that a cellphone user had no reasonable expectation of privacy when dialing numbers.  Since the wireless carrier maintains them for their record, the user knowingly exposes this information regardless.

Should a search warrant be required anyway?

Given the progression of technology in the area of mobile devices since 1987, they have become more than just a device used for communication purposes.  In this day in age, cellphones contain a wealth data that could be private to the user.

Taking this progression into consideration, privacy should be assumed by the user.  A person cannot use the device without first having to share their information with the wireless carrier.  

This inherent problem should not be turned into a dilemma of whether or not to use a cellphone.  Thus, the burden to maintain a certain level of privacy should be on the carrier and not the user.

Protection under the Constitution.

The Fourth Amendment of the United States Constitution citizens enjoy the protection from unreasonable searches and seizures.  The user may voluntary disclose this information, but privacy should still be maintained.  Wireless users should not have to fear their private information could be released when using their own property.

Privacy concerns still remain.

The court may have had their motives for declining the case, but privacy concerns still remain.  Mobile devices have advanced over the years, and the law should allow for users to maintain privacy in their effects. Therefore, wireless carriers should have a higher level of privacy when releasing customer data.

Criminal Case Problems? Call today!

If you have a matter regarding a search and seizure violation of your cell phone, please do not hesitate to contact The Law Offices of Tina M. Barberi at (559) 447-1240 to discuss your case.  

Posted on
January 16, 2016
in
Fresno Criminal Law Posts
category
4th Amendment, attorney at law, California lawyer, cellphone, cellphone location data, cellphone privacy, constitution, privacy, search

Making the Right Decision Under Proposition 47

Locked up for life without Prop 47? Before you apply for relief, make sure you a criminal lawyer that understands Prop 47.
Criminal
Tina Barberi, DUI and criminal lawyer in Fresno will fight to win your criminal and DUI case.
Tina M. Barberi
March 23, 2015
Proposition 47 is a great for so many citizens in California, but how do you know if you qualify for it? The best way to know for sure is to read this summary so you can check if you can get Prop 47 relief in Fresno County.

California AB 1950 and Reduction in the Length of Probation in Fresno

CA AB 1950 reduce probation with dui and criminal defense lawyer in Fresno
Criminal
Tina Barberi, DUI and criminal lawyer in Fresno will fight to win your criminal and DUI case.
Tina M. Barberi
December 22, 2020
On January 1, 2021, California's new law, AB 1950, will reduce the length of probation for most criminal charges. Now, many people convicted of a felony or a misdemeanor will receive a shorter probation sentence.

Fresno County Tough on Petty Theft Charges

Petty theft and shoplifting in Fresno will be prosecuted without having the proper criminal lawyer that understands theft charges.
Criminal
Tina Barberi, DUI and criminal lawyer in Fresno will fight to win your criminal and DUI case.
Tina M. Barberi
April 16, 2015
Have you been arrested or accused of petty theft? If so, you need to read the steps you need to take to keep from getting a petty theft conviction in Fresno County. This blog will explain the charge and how you can fight it.

Plea Agreements in Fresno? Avoid the Pitfalls.

How to plea bargain so you get the best deal possible for your criminal case. Best DUI and criminal lawyers know how to beat criminal charges.
Criminal
Tina Barberi, DUI and criminal lawyer in Fresno will fight to win your criminal and DUI case.
Tina M. Barberi
May 25, 2016
Plea bargaining is commonly used in the Fresno criminal courts by district attorneys and lawyers, but how do you know if it is right for you? If you have ever wondered why plea bargaining is used, do not miss out on this post.

SR-22 Auto Insurance after Fresno DUI

A criminal lawyer can determine if you need a SR-22 insurance for your car after a DUI arrest and DMV hearing in Fresno.
Traffic
Tina Barberi, DUI and criminal lawyer in Fresno will fight to win your criminal and DUI case.
Tina M. Barberi
March 16, 2015
What is an SR-22 and do you need it? If your license is suspended because of a DUI, you will be required to have an SR-22 before a license is issued. But you may avoid the SR-22 requirement by reading this post first.

What is Driving a Vehicle under Fresno DUI Laws?

A DUI can be proven even if the officer did not see you drive unless you retain a criminal defense attorney in Fresno.
DUI
Tina Barberi, DUI and criminal lawyer in Fresno will fight to win your criminal and DUI case.
Tina M. Barberi
March 1, 2015
If you want to know what the law says about driving under the DUI laws, you will want to read this post. There are various problems when a person is not driving a vehicle and is accused of drinking and driving.

Any rights in our car? US Supreme Court Says No!

Traffic lawyer in Fresno will defend unconstitutional searches and seizures by police in California. Make sure to hire an attorney.
Traffic
Tina Barberi, DUI and criminal lawyer in Fresno will fight to win your criminal and DUI case.
Tina M. Barberi
April 20, 2015
Are you safe from police intrusion? Find out what the Supreme Court said about officers and their mistakes. If the officer can be wrong about the law, then why can't we? See how you can protect yourself when driving in Fresno.

What You Must Know if You are Arrested for a DUI.

Illegal searches and seizure cases are difficult to prove without an experienced criminal law firm in Fresno, California.
DUI
Tina Barberi, DUI and criminal lawyer in Fresno will fight to win your criminal and DUI case.
Tina M. Barberi
May 16, 2015
DUI arrests are complicated and in order to fight a DUI, you must understand how an officer can arrest you on suspicion of DUI. Learn what it takes for an officer to prove you are guilty of a DUI and how to defend yourself.

Happy Veterans Day! Let's Celebrate Our Brave Soldiers

Criminal lawyers will help you when you are charged with a Drunk driving this Veteran's Day.
Our Firm
Criminal, Traffic and DUI defense Fresno, CA
Law Offices
November 11, 2015
Fresno Police Department is patrolling this weekend for suspected drunk drivers in Fresno. If you are drinking during the holiday weekend, please make sure to not drink and drive. If you have facing charges, get help now.

Motions to Suppress in Criminal Cases in Fresno

Illegal detentions, searches and seizures are serious and without a criminal attorney, it is difficult to win a suppression motion.
DUI
Criminal, Traffic and DUI defense Fresno, CA
Law Offices
March 6, 2015
Motion to suppress hearings are a way to show the police illegally searched or seized evidence illegally. Make sure you understand what these motions are and how to use them when you are facing criminal charges.

Celebrate Your Boss on National Boss Day!

Traffic lawyer in Fresno is the best Boss and attorney. Tina Barberi will make sure you get great service for your DUI case.
Our Firm
Criminal, Traffic and DUI defense Fresno, CA
Law Offices
October 16, 2015
National Boss Day is a special day to tell your boss how much they mean to you. For Tina, we decided to surprise her with a blog because she has been working so hard on her website and we hope she will enjoy it.

Speedy Trial Violations: Dismissals are Possible

Fresno courts must dismiss the case against you even if you are guilty when your rights are violated in Fresno with the right attorney.
Criminal
Criminal, Traffic and DUI defense Fresno, CA
Law Offices
April 18, 2016
The government is required to prosecute you within a reasonable period of time, and when there is a violation of a speedy trial right, it is serious. See if your case should be dismissed when the district attorney violates the law.

You Might Also Like