Discovery in DUI Cases
Discovery is the process where both the defense and prosecution exchange evidence relevant to the case. For DUI charges, this evidence could include police reports, body camera footage, results from chemical tests (such as blood or breath tests), and any additional observations made by the arresting officer.
The details often begin with the traffic stop itself. A police officer may pull you over for a routine traffic violation or erratic driving behavior that raises suspicion of impairment. From there, the officer evaluates signs of intoxication, such as slurred speech, alcohol odor, or poor coordination, to establish probable cause.
It is the prosecution’s legal obligation to provide all evidence in their possession, especially anything that could suggest your innocence. If evidence is delayed, incomplete, or withheld, your attorney may act by filing motions to ensure your rights are upheld. A skilled DUI lawyer will analyze the discovery materials to identify errors or weaknesses that could lead to a dismissal, suppression of evidence, or other favorable outcomes.
Pre-Trial Hearings
The pre-trial phase provides opportunities to resolve procedural issues and negotiate with the prosecution. During these hearings, your attorney may discuss plea bargains with the district attorney, which might involve reduced charges, lesser penalties, or participation in alternative sentencing programs.
Most DUI cases do not proceed to trial. A large percentage of these cases are resolved during the pre-trial stage through negotiation. This is especially true when the prosecutor’s case has vulnerabilities that your attorney highlights. Plea bargains can be an efficient way to move past a DUI charge with minimized consequences, but the decision to accept or decline an offer should always be made with input from an experienced lawyer.
Motions in DUI Cases
Pre-trial motions are a critical component of DUI defense. These legal requests ask the court to take specific actions, such as excluding certain evidence or dismissing particular charges. The most frequent motion in DUI cases is a motion to suppress evidence based on constitutional violations. For example, if an officer conducted an unlawful traffic stop or improperly obtained chemical test results, your attorney may challenge the admissibility of that evidence.
For felony DUIs, additional motions, such as Penal Code 995 motions, may be filed. These motions aim to dismiss charges for reasons like insufficient evidence, procedural errors during preliminary hearings, or constitutional violations. Effective motions can substantially weaken the prosecution's case, sometimes resulting in dismissal or reduced charges.
DUI Trials and the Right to a Jury Trial
If plea negotiations fail and your case proceeds to trial, your right to a jury trial becomes essential. At this stage, both sides present evidence, examine and cross-examine witnesses, and make legal arguments before a jury.
Your DUI attorney will have an opportunity to scrutinize the testimony of the prosecution’s witnesses, including the arresting officer, and highlight inconsistencies or flaws in the case against you. Defense witnesses may also be presented to support alternative interpretations of the facts. A proactive DUI attorney is critical during trial, because we can challenge the evidence and present your case persuasively to the jury.
DUI Sentencing
Sentencing occurs if you are convicted or enter a guilty plea. Penalties for DUIs in California can be severe, ranging from fines and required educational programs to jail time and long-term license suspension. For repeat offenses or cases involving aggravating factors, like injuries or high BAC levels, the consequences can be especially harsh.
However, sentencing is not the end of the line. A skilled DUI attorney will advocate for the lightest penalties possible, emphasizing mitigating factors such as your willingness to comply with alternative sentencing, your clean criminal record, or hardships that might justify leniency.
If your charges are dismissed or you are acquitted at trial, you can put the episode behind you quickly and move forward with your life. If convicted, your lawyer will work diligently to minimize the impact on your future.